Free agent squads are the coed league version of a reality show. No one knows what to expect; you have to spend two months together, and everyone either implodes or finds out they can’t go back to their former life before Footy.

If you’re debating whether to rejoin your free agent team next season or turn on your very own incognito mode, here are five signs the universe is telling you it makes total sense to stick together.

Free agent teams: start with a polite nod and before you know it, you’ll be hand slapping all day.

Sign #1: You didn’t have to Google anyone’s name by Week 2

You know who passes, who shoots, and who yells “man on!” a little too much. If names are locked in, positions are settling, and people actually talk to each other on and off the field, you’ve got team chemistry. Don’t take it for granted.

Sign #2: You scored… and five people screamed like you just won the World Cup on PK’s.

The energy is authentic. If your team celebrates each other’s goals (even the ones that bounce off someone’s shin and roll in slow motion), you’re playing with folks who care—and that’s half the battle. Stay with the people who make you feel like a star, even when your assist was originally designed to be a “just get this player off me” pass.

**Sign #3: Nobody’s taking it too seriously**

If someone shouts “RELAX!” every time you mess up a pass… yeah, run. But if your crew is cool with the occasional airball, slip-up, or overly ambitious nutmeg attempt? That’s a green flag. Stick with teammates who can maintain a competitive and fun atmosphere.

Sign #4: Post-game food & drink meetups feel right

No team’s strategy to get to the playoffs survives on an empty stomach. If someone’s putting in the social work to turn your team into something more than a jersey color, consider that person your unofficial MVP. You’re here for soccer and community. Both matter.

Sign #5: You're already talking about next season

If everyone has Fall rollover registration’s opening date circled on the calendar and knows all about that Squab Goal 15% off discount, it’s a done deal. You’re in deeper than you thought. And that’s not a bad thing. So get ready to run it back. You’ve got something good going.

TL;DR:

If your team shows up, supports each other, and can take a joke, don’t overthink it. Free agent magic doesn’t strike every season—when it does, lock it in and build something even better.